Researching a business before you buy it: liens, debts, lawsuits and other hidden risk
How to find what others can claim against a business before you buy it, what each kind of search shows, and how to protect yourself once you know.
Before you buy a business, you look in the public record for what other people can claim against it: liens on equipment and inventory, unpaid taxes, court judgments, lawsuits and unpaid bills. You also read its contracts for terms that end or change when ownership changes. What you find decides what is paid off at closing, what the seller stays responsible for, and how much money is held back.
What risk means in a purchase
A business comes with other people’s claims on it. Some are written down in public records, some sit in its contracts, and some only show up in how it runs.
Three kinds of risk matter. Financial risk is debts, taxes and numbers that do not hold up. Legal risk is liens, judgments, lawsuits, and contracts that cannot be assigned. Operational risk is the practical side: a key employee who could leave, a license in the owner’s name, equipment that is worn out.
How much of it comes with you depends on the structure. In an asset purchase the buyer takes the assets and usually leaves the seller’s debts behind, except those it agrees to assume. In a stock purchase the buyer takes the company, and every debt and claim stays inside it. Even in an asset purchase, a court can in some situations hold the buyer responsible for the seller’s debts: where the buyer agreed to take them on, where the deal is in substance a merger, where the new business is really the old one continuing under the same owners and management, or where the sale was meant to defeat the seller’s creditors.
The risk map: what to look for and where
No single search finds everything. These are the main places to look, and what usually happens when something turns up.
| What to look for | Where it shows up | What usually happens when found |
|---|---|---|
| Liens on equipment, inventory or receivables | UCC filings at the New York Department of State, searched by the seller’s exact name | A payoff letter and release at closing, paid out of the price. |
| Unpaid tax, state tax warrants, federal tax liens | Separate Department of State and federal lien searches, plus the seller’s sales tax and payroll filings | Paid from the proceeds, or held back until the State or IRS confirms the amount. |
| Court judgments | County and court records, searched separately from UCC filings | Paid and released at closing. |
| Lawsuits and threatened claims | Court records, the seller’s own list, insurance claims history, letters from lawyers | Listed in the contract, kept by the seller, or covered by an indemnity or escrow. |
| Accounts payable and other debts | Payables aging, vendor and lender statements, leases, credit cards | Assumed or excluded by name in the contract, or paid at closing. |
| Contracts that end or change on a change of ownership | The contracts themselves: assignment and change-of-control clauses | Written consent before closing, a new contract, or a lower price. |
| Lapsed or non-transferable licenses and permits | The licenses, and the agencies that issued them | Fixed before closing, or the buyer applies for its own. |
| Employee and worker claims | Payroll filings, worker classification, workers’ compensation history, wage complaints | A specific promise and indemnity, or a price change. |
| Environmental problems (when real estate is included) | An environmental site assessment, permits and past reports | A review before closing, and a price or condition that reflects it. |
Liens and the UCC search
A lien is a creditor’s claim on property that stays attached to it until the debt is paid. A UCC financing statement is the public filing a lender makes to claim a business’s equipment, inventory or receivables as collateral for a loan. In New York these are filed with the Department of State and searched by the debtor’s exact name. A variation of the name may not appear in a standard search, and each name needs its own search request. Most filings lapse after five years unless the lender renews them.
So the search covers every name the business has used: the company name, trade names, former names and the owner’s name where the owner personally pledged assets. Tax warrants and court judgments are searched separately, and the Department’s UCC search does not cover judgment liens. The Department’s own FAQ also warns that its federal tax lien search does not return name variants.
A hit is not a deal-breaker. It is a debt that has to be paid or released. The lender is asked for a payoff figure, and at closing the payoff is wired out of the purchase price and a release is delivered for each filing.
Judgments, lawsuits and claims
A judgment is a court’s order that a debt is owed; once recorded it can become a lien on the debtor’s property. Lawsuits that are pending, threatened or recently settled matter for a different reason: they show what the business is exposed to, and an unlisted claim can become the buyer’s problem.
This search has several parts. Court and county records are searched for cases and judgments against the business and its owner. The seller is asked for a list of every pending or threatened claim, every demand letter, and every insurance claim in recent years, and the answers are compared with what the searches show. Inspection and violation history is requested for businesses that have inspections, such as restaurants and manufacturers. A claim the seller did not mention is a finding in its own right.
Unpaid taxes
Sales tax and payroll tax are the two debts most likely to follow a buyer. Sales tax returns and proof of payment are requested for every period, and payroll filings are checked against the employee list. See checking the financials.
New York adds a rule for buyers. A buyer of a business that collects sales tax generally must file a notice with the State Tax Department at least 10 days before paying or taking over any of the assets. A buyer that skips it can be held personally liable for the seller’s unpaid sales tax, up to the greater of the price paid or the fair market value of the assets bought. The full steps are on the bulk sale notice page.
Accounts payable and other debts
Accounts payable are the bills the business owes to suppliers and others. Together with loans, leases, credit cards and customer deposits, they are the debts the buyer either assumes by name or leaves behind.
- In an asset purchase the contract lists the debts the buyer assumes. Anything not listed is an excluded liability and stays with the seller.
- In a stock purchase every debt of the company comes with it, whether or not anyone listed it.
- Debts to be paid off at closing come out of the price on a closing statement, so the buyer is not left paying a creditor it did not agree to pay.
- Debts nobody listed are the reason the contract includes a seller’s promise that all debts have been disclosed, and a way to be repaid if one appears later. See representations and warranties.
Buyers also look for personal guarantees, rent that is behind, equipment leases, and obligations to customers such as prepaid orders and gift cards.
Contracts that can end when ownership changes
Two clauses decide whether a contract moves with the business. An anti-assignment clause says the contract cannot be transferred without the other side’s consent. A change-of-control clause lets the other side end or change the contract when ownership of the business changes. The second catches a stock purchase, where nothing is “assigned” but the owner is different.
Buyers read the lease, the top customer and supplier contracts, equipment leases, software and licensing agreements, insurance policies, and any franchise or dealer agreement. A contract with a State agency generally needs the agency’s consent to be assigned; whether a sale of the company’s stock triggers it depends on the contract’s own wording. For each, the question is the same: does it need consent, will the other side give it, and what is the price of asking? The process is covered in leases, licenses and consents.
Operational and legal risk
Some risk does not show up in any record search. It shows up in how the business actually runs.
- Dependence on a person. Customers who call the owner, or one employee who holds the key relationships. See employees and key people.
- Dependence on a customer or supplier. A large share of sales from one customer, or one sole-source supplier.
- Licenses and accounts in the wrong name. Licenses, domain names, phone numbers and online accounts held by the owner personally.
- Equipment. Age, condition, maintenance records, and whether it is owned, leased or pledged.
- Worker classification and wage claims. People treated as contractors who may be employees under New York’s test.
- Insurance. What coverage exists, what claims have been made, and whether the policies continue after the sale.
- Environmental condition where real estate is part of the deal. A buyer of contaminated property can qualify for federal landowner protection only if it did an environmental review known as “all appropriate inquiries” (a Phase I environmental site assessment) within a year before buying, and meets continuing duties afterward.
What is involved: protecting yourself
Research shows what the risks are. These are the tools that put protection in the deal.
- Choose the structure. An asset purchase can leave debts behind; a stock purchase cannot. See asset or stock purchase.
- List what is assumed and what is excluded. The contract names the debts and contracts the buyer takes on, and states that everything else stays with the seller.
- Pay off liens and debts at closing. Payoff letters are collected in advance, the amounts come out of the price on the closing statement, and a release is delivered for each lien.
- The bulk sale notice is filed before paying, and the buyer generally waits for the release or the five-business-day window. The Department’s instructions tie holding the price in escrow to a buyer that receives a notice of claim (Form AU-196.2), and say a buyer may pay if no notice of claim comes within five business days.
- Get the seller’s promises in writing. The seller promises that debts, taxes and claims have been disclosed, and the contract gives the buyer a way to be repaid if one appears. See representations and warranties.
- Hold part of the price back. An escrow or holdback keeps money available for claims during an agreed period. See indemnification and escrow.
- Make consents and licenses conditions of closing. If a landlord, customer or agency must say yes, the buyer is not required to close until it does.
- Review the insurance. New coverage for the buyer starts at closing, and the seller may buy extra time on its old policy for claims that surface later.
- An environmental review is common when real estate is included.
Questions about researching a business
Short answers. For your own deal, the best answer comes from a conversation.
How do I check a business for liens?
Do I buy the seller’s debts if I buy the business?
What if a lawsuit turns up that the seller did not mention?
Can research find everything?
Where we work. Seraj Law is a Capital Region firm with clients across New York State. See the counties and towns we serve.
Attorney Advertising
The information on this website is for general informational purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Talk to an attorney about your deal.
Reach out to us. We quote a flat fee for the work. Open 7 days a week, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m.
This page provides general legal information about researching a business before buying it in New York and is not legal advice. Do not send confidential information through this site before we have agreed to represent you.