What representations and warranties are
A representation is a statement of fact about the business, such as “the financial statements are accurate.” A warranty is a promise that the statement is true, and that promise is what gives the buyer a right to be paid if it is not. Purchase agreements combine the two, and people say “reps and warranties” or just “reps.”
The seller makes them in the purchase agreement as of the signing date, and usually again at closing. The second time is called a bring-down: the seller confirms that everything is still true, often in a closing certificate. If a statement was untrue, the buyer may be able to recover its loss from the seller. Unless the statement is limited by what the seller knew, an honest mistake generally does not excuse it.
Why they exist. A buyer cannot inspect everything during the due diligence period. The statements put the risk of what diligence missed on the seller, and they push the seller to check its own records before signing. For both sides, collecting the exceptions is the moment when problems come out, while they can still be priced or fixed.
How a buyer is paid when a statement is wrong is covered on the indemnification, escrow and holdbacks page.
The statements a buyer usually asks for
The list changes with the business, but most small and mid-size purchase agreements cover the same ground. The right-hand column shows what each statement is checked against, because a statement nobody checks is a promise nobody has tested.
Typical statements in a business purchase agreement| Topic | What the seller states | What it is checked against |
|---|
| Financial statements | The statements for the periods given were prepared consistently and fairly show the results and financial position of the business. | Tax returns, bank statements, sales records and the accountant’s work. See checking the financials. |
|---|
| Undisclosed liabilities | The business has no debts or obligations other than those on the balance sheet, those on a schedule, and those that arose in ordinary operations since. | Accounts payable aging, loan documents, lien searches, vendor statements. See researching risk. |
|---|
| Taxes | Returns were filed and taxes paid, with no audits or notices pending. Sales tax was collected and sent in. | Filed returns, notices, sales tax and payroll filings. |
|---|
| Title to assets | The seller owns what it is selling, free of liens other than those listed, and the equipment is in working order. | Lien searches, titles, the equipment list, lender payoff letters. |
|---|
| Contracts | Listed contracts are valid and in force, nobody is in default, and none ends or changes because of the sale. | Copies of every contract, and the assignment and change-of-control clauses in them. |
|---|
| Lawsuits and claims | No pending or threatened lawsuits, claims or investigations, except those listed. | Court record searches, insurance claim history, demand letters. |
|---|
| Licenses and permits | The business holds every license and permit it needs, they are in force, and there are no violations. | Copies of the licenses and agency records. See leases, licenses and consents. |
|---|
| Employees | The employee list and pay are accurate, workers are correctly classified as employees or contractors, and wages are paid. | Payroll records, contractor agreements, workers’ compensation records. See employees and key people. |
|---|
| Compliance with law | The business has followed the laws that apply to it and has received no notice of violation. | Inspection reports, agency notices, regulatory letters. |
|---|
| No changes since the last balance sheet | Since the date of the latest financial statements the business has run in the ordinary course, with no large loss, no sale of major assets and no big change in customers. | Monthly financials and customer lists, compared month to month. |
|---|
Which ones carry the most weight depends on the business. A restaurant buyer presses on permits and sales tax. A manufacturer’s buyer presses on equipment, environmental history and a few large customers. See documents by type of business.
Disclosure schedules: the exceptions
The disclosure schedules are lists attached to the agreement that give the exceptions to each statement: “there are no lawsuits, except those on Schedule 3.9.” A statement qualified by a schedule is not broken by what the schedule lists. A fully disclosed issue generally cannot support a later claim for a broken statement.
That makes the schedules the place where much of the real sharing of risk happens. For a buyer, each item on a schedule is a problem to price, to have fixed before closing, or to cover with a separate indemnity for that item. For a seller, a specific schedule item is protection: the buyer cannot later say it was surprised by something it was told. Points that get negotiated:
- Specific or general disclosure. A buyer wants an item to count only against the statement it is listed under. A seller wants any item on any schedule to qualify every statement it could relate to.
- Detail. “Various disputes” is worth little. A list with the case name, the court and the amount in question is worth a lot, to both sides.
- Updates between signing and closing. If something new comes up in the weeks before closing, can the seller add it to the schedules? A buyer asks that an update does not cure the problem and may let it refuse to close. A seller asks that an update cures it if the buyer closes anyway.
- Source. The schedules usually come out of due diligence: the same documents, the same questions. A schedule built from memory misses things.
Qualifiers that change what a statement is worth
The same sentence can be a strong promise or a weak one, depending on the words around it.
- Knowledge qualifier. “To the seller’s knowledge” limits a statement to what the seller actually knows. Two points to settle: whose knowledge counts (the owner only, or managers as well), and whether it means what they actually know or what they would have learned after reasonable inquiry.
- Materiality qualifier. “In all material respects” means a small, harmless error does not make the statement untrue. A buyer may ask for a materiality scrape: once a statement is found untrue, the word “material” is ignored when the loss is counted, so the whole loss counts.
- Time. Statements about the past and present are normal. A statement that sales will reach a target is a forecast, and a seller usually does not give one.
- Catch-all statements. Buyers often ask for a statement that nothing the seller provided was misleading or left something out. It is broad and hard to defend, and sellers usually resist it or narrow it.
What a buyer asks for and what a seller resists
What a buyer asks for
- A statement for each area where the business could hurt it, matched to the diligence list.
- The statements made at signing and again at closing.
- Few or no knowledge and materiality qualifiers on the most basic statements.
- A longer life and a higher limit for the basic statements.
- Its rights kept even if it learned of a problem before closing.
- A catch-all statement that nothing material was left out.
What a seller negotiates or resists
- Knowledge qualifiers on anything outside its control: what customers plan, what third parties do.
- Materiality limits, so a small error is not a broken promise.
- Statements about the past and present only, with no forecasts.
- No catch-all statement, or a narrow one.
- Specific disclosure, with schedule updates allowed.
- Every statement read against its own records before it agrees. The first draft often asks for more than the facts support.
Basic statements, fraud and how long statements last
Not every statement is treated alike. The fundamental representations are usually that the seller exists and has authority to sell, that it owns what it is selling, and often that taxes were paid. They typically last longer than the general statements and are often outside the general limit on what the seller can owe.
General statements last for a stated period after closing, called the survival period, and a total limit applies, called the cap. Fraud is usually outside both. A statement that expires at closing is worth nothing, so how long each one lasts decides whether it matters. Both are covered on the indemnification page.
When the buyer already knows a statement is untrue
Suppose the buyer learns during diligence that a statement in the draft is wrong, and closes anyway. Can it still make a claim afterward? Lawyers call this sandbagging. The answer depends on what the contract says and, if the contract is silent, on the law. New York courts have looked at how the buyer learned of the problem, and a buyer that closes knowing a statement is false may in some situations lose the claim unless the contract preserves it.
So agreements usually say which way it goes. A buyer asks for a clause that what it knew does not affect its rights. A seller asks for a clause that a known problem cannot be claimed. A buyer who finds a problem often has it fixed, priced or covered by a specific indemnity before closing instead of relying on the statement.
Insurance as an alternative
Representations and warranties insurance is a policy, usually bought by the buyer, that pays for some losses caused by untrue statements. It can reduce or replace the escrow and in some deals becomes the buyer’s main remedy, it is more common in larger deals, and it excludes problems known before the policy starts. If a policy is on the table, it is usually raised early, since it changes how much the seller has to stand behind.
What is involved
- A first draft of the statements is written, often by the buyer’s side, usually from a standard list. It is then reshaped to the actual business.
- Each statement is read against the records: the financial statements against the tax returns, the contract list against the contracts, the permit list against copies of the permits.
- The exceptions are collected into the disclosure schedules: lawsuits, liens, contract defaults, permits still pending. Collecting them takes time, so it starts before the agreement is final.
- Qualifiers are negotiated: whose knowledge counts, where materiality applies, whether a catch-all stays.
- The life and limit of the statements are set: the survival period, the cap, the basket and how the buyer is paid.
- Between signing and closing, new facts are reported, and the schedule-update rule decides what they do to the deal.
- At closing, the bring-down certificate confirms the statements are still true.
- After closing, any claim follows the process written into the agreement.