Skip to main content
Seraj Law
Mergers & Acquisitions · Buyers and sellers

Indemnification, escrow and holdbacks in a business sale

How long and how much a seller can owe after closing, and how a buyer is paid if a problem turns up. Seraj Law is a Capital Region firm that represents business buyers and sellers across New York State.

The short answer

Indemnification is the seller’s promise to reimburse the buyer for losses from an untrue statement or a named problem after closing. It is limited by a survival period (how long), a cap (how much) and a basket (a minimum before claims count), and it is backed by an escrow, a holdback or set-off against later payments. Fraud is usually not limited. None of these terms has a standard figure; each is negotiated.

What indemnification is

Indemnification is the seller’s contract promise to reimburse the buyer for certain losses after closing. It is how the representations and warranties get teeth: without it, a buyer who finds a problem would have to sue for breach of contract and prove its damages from scratch.

A purchase agreement usually names three triggers:

  • A statement that was untrue. A representation or warranty that turns out to be false.
  • A promise that was broken. Something the seller agreed to do, or not to do, such as running the business normally until closing.
  • A named problem. A specific item the agreement says the seller pays for whatever the cause, such as taxes from before closing, a known lawsuit, or a debt the buyer did not agree to take on. This is called a specific indemnity and is often kept outside the general limits.

The agreement then sets limits, because neither side wants open-ended risk. The seller wants to know where its exposure ends. The buyer wants to be sure the promise is worth something when a claim comes.

The limits: how long, how much, and above what amount

These terms do not remove the seller’s exposure. They set where it starts and stops. All of them are negotiated, so the table shows what each side usually asks for, not what is standard.

Limits on indemnification, in plain English
TermWhat it isBuyer usually asksSeller usually asks
Survival periodHow long after closing a claim for an untrue statement can still be made. The length is set in the agreement, and tax and ownership statements often last longer.A period long enough to catch a full tax year and an audit cycle.As short as it can be, so the end of exposure is visible.
CapThe most the seller can owe in total for untrue statements. Fraud is usually not capped.A high cap, with the basic statements outside it.A cap well below the price that covers everything, often tied to the size of the escrow.
BasketA minimum amount of losses before claims count. It is a threshold, not protection against large claims. In a deductible basket the buyer recovers only the amount above the line. In a threshold (“first-dollar” or “tipping”) basket the buyer recovers everything once the line is crossed.A low line and first-dollar recovery.A higher line and a deductible.
Per-claim minimumClaims below a set size do not count and do not add up toward the basket.No minimum, or a very low one.A minimum, so small claims do not pile up.
Basic (“fundamental”) statementsOwnership of the assets, authority to sell and often taxes. They typically last longer and sit outside the general cap and basket.Longer life, higher limit, no basket.The same limits as everything else, or a limit tied to the price.
Exclusive remedyThe agreement’s claim process is the buyer’s only remedy for the covered statements.Exceptions for fraud and for specific indemnities.Yes, so the buyer cannot sue around the cap and the survival period.

We do not print “market” percentages for caps, baskets or escrows here. Figures quoted online mostly come from larger deals or unsourced posts, and what is reasonable depends on the size of the deal, the buyer, and how clean the records are.

Two points apply in every deal. Fraud is usually outside the cap and the survival period. And a limit only helps the side it favors if it is written clearly, so each definition (“loss,” “claim,” “knowledge”) matters as much as the number.

Escrow, holdback and set‑off: how the money is secured

An indemnity is only as good as the seller’s ability to pay. If the seller is a company that will pay out the sale proceeds to its owners and wind down, the buyer may have no one to collect from. So the agreement usually sets aside money or gives the buyer a way to hold it. Three methods are common:

Three ways a buyer secures its claims
MethodHow it worksSeller’s riskBuyer’s risk
EscrowPart of the price is deposited at closing with a neutral third party, usually a bank or escrow agent, and held for a set period. Valid claims are paid to the buyer. At the end, the rest goes to the seller. Amounts tied to a claim still pending stay held.The money is tied up for the escrow period. Sellers often seek objective release dates, a limited amount, and release of the balance when the period ends.The amount may be smaller than the loss.
HoldbackThe buyer keeps part of the price itself and pays it later if there are no claims.Reliance on the buyer’s willingness and ability to pay. Sellers often ask for an escrow, or for security.None beyond a dispute over what is owed.
Set-offThe buyer reduces a later payment it owes the seller, such as a seller note or earnout payment, by the amount of its claim.The buyer can cut later payments on its own say-so. A seller asks that set-off apply only to claims it agrees to or that a neutral has confirmed.Only works while later payments remain.

A seller note and an earnout bring set-off into the picture. See earnouts and seller notes. Sometimes the seller’s owner is asked to guarantee the promise personally, which gives the buyer someone to collect from after the company has paid out.

A separate hold on money can apply in a New York deal that involves a business collecting sales tax. The State Tax Department’s instructions tie holding the price in escrow to a buyer that receives a notice of claim (Form AU-196.2), and say a buyer may pay if no notice of claim comes within five business days. See the bulk sale notice.

What happens after closing

  1. Closing day

    Escrow is funded

    The escrow agreement is signed, the escrow amount is deposited from the price, and the closing statement shows it. The survival clock starts.

  2. During the survival period

    The buyer watches for problems

    If a problem appears, the buyer sends a written claim notice. The agreement says how fast, and how detailed, the notice has to be.

  3. When a claim arrives

    The seller responds

    The seller has a stated time to accept or dispute the claim. A claim is not a judgment. If it is accepted, it is paid from the escrow first, then by the seller or by set-off, as the agreement says. If it is disputed, the dispute process starts: negotiation first, then an independent accountant for a numbers question, or a court or arbitration for a legal one.

  4. If a third party sues the buyer

    Control of the defense

    Some claims come from outside, such as a customer or former employee suing over something that happened before closing. The agreement says who controls the defense and whether the other side must agree before a settlement.

  5. When the survival period ends

    Release

    Money not tied to a pending claim is released to the seller. Money tied to a pending claim stays held until it is resolved.

  6. Later price changes

    Tax paperwork

    A payment from escrow or an indemnity payment can change the price after closing. If the price changes after closing, a supplemental Form 8594 may be needed. See price allocation.

What each side negotiates

What a buyer asks for

  • An escrow or holdback large enough to matter, held for the full survival period.
  • Specific indemnities for known problems, outside the cap.
  • A guarantee or set-off right when the seller is a company that will pay out and dissolve.
  • Basic statements to last longer and carry a higher limit.
  • A claim notice rule that is easy to meet.

What a seller negotiates

  • The amount held and how long: a limited amount, for a stated period.
  • Release dates that are objective, not “when the buyer is satisfied.”
  • That the escrow is the first source of payment and, for most claims, the only one.
  • A claim process with notice, detail and a fair time to respond.
  • A neutral decision-maker for numbers disputes, and limits on set-off.
  • Insurance on the buyer’s side as a way to shrink the escrow. See representations and warranties insurance.

What is involved

  1. Decide which promises carry which limits. General statements, basic statements, covenants and specific indemnities are not treated alike.
  2. Set the numbers: the survival periods, the cap, the basket and any per-claim minimum, stated in dollars or as a clear formula.
  3. Choose how the money is secured: escrow, holdback, set-off against later payments, an owner guarantee, or a combination.
  4. If there is an escrow, an escrow agent is selected, the escrow agreement is written (amount, investment of the funds, release dates, what happens with a pending claim), and the fees are assigned.
  5. Write the claim process: notice, detail, response time, dispute resolution, third-party claims.
  6. Address taxes: who pays tax for the period before closing, and how a tax audit of that period is handled.
  7. Check the pieces against each other: the cap against the escrow, set-off against the seller note, the exclusive remedy clause against fraud.
  8. After closing, the dates are calendared: the claim deadlines and the release date.
Questions

Questions about indemnification and escrow

Short answers. For your own agreement, the answer is in the wording.

Can I be sued after the survival period ends?
Claims for general statements usually cannot be started after it ends, but a claim noticed before then generally continues. Fraud claims, and statements about ownership, authority and taxes, often have longer or separate time limits. The exact answer is in the agreement.
What is the difference between an escrow and a holdback?
In an escrow a neutral third party holds part of the price. In a holdback the buyer keeps that part itself and pays it later. An escrow protects the seller if the buyer’s finances change. A holdback is simpler and cheaper to set up, but the seller is relying on the buyer.
Does a cap protect me from a fraud claim?
Generally not. Caps and baskets limit claims for honest mistakes. Fraud is normally carved out of them. A seller who has been accurate in what it told the buyer is the best protected.
When do I get the escrow money back?
At the release date in the escrow agreement, less any claims paid and less any amount tied to a claim still pending. Sellers often ask for objective release dates and for partial releases if the period is long.
Where we work. Seraj Law is a Capital Region firm with its office in Albany, and we represent buyers and sellers across New York State. See the counties and towns we work in

Attorney Advertising

The information on this website is for general informational purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Talk to an attorney about your deal.

Reach out to us. We quote a flat fee for the work. Open 7 days a week, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m.

This page provides general legal information about indemnification, escrow and holdbacks in a business sale in New York and is not legal advice or tax advice. Do not send confidential information through this site before we have agreed to represent you.