Why consents decide whether a deal closes
A business is a bundle of agreements: a lease, supplier and customer contracts, loans, equipment leases, licenses and permits. In an asset purchase, the buyer chooses which assets and contracts it takes, and each contract has to be assigned (moved) to the buyer, often with the other side’s written consent (permission). In a stock purchase the company keeps its contracts, but many contracts contain a change-of-control clause: a term that treats a change in who owns the company as if it were an assignment, so consent is needed anyway.
Consents matter because the other side holds the power. A landlord can say no, a franchisor can say no, and a licensing agency can take time. A late consent delays closing, and one that never arrives can end the deal or change its price. A request that has been sent is not a consent that has been given, so the closing file holds the signed consent itself.
The commercial lease: what to read
For a shop, restaurant, office or workshop, the lease is often the most valuable thing being sold, because it decides whether the business can stay where its customers are. A buyer reads it before agreeing to a price, and a seller who knows what it says can fix problems before a buyer finds them. The terms that usually matter:
- Remaining term and renewal options. The same business is worth more with ten years of lease ahead than with eight months left and no right to renew. Lenders look at this too.
- Rent and increases. Current rent, scheduled increases, and how rent is reset at renewal.
- Who pays what. Under a net lease the tenant pays its share of the building’s taxes, insurance and common-area costs on top of base rent. Buyers often ask for the history of those charges.
- Deposit and guarantees. How much the landlord holds, and whether the owner signed a personal guarantee: a promise to pay the rent if the business does not.
- Permitted use and exclusives. What the space may be used for, and whether the lease keeps competitors out of the building.
- Assignment and subletting. Whether the tenant may transfer the lease, and on what conditions.
- Retail extras. Percentage rent (extra rent based on sales) and co-tenancy clauses (rent relief if an anchor tenant leaves).
Property management and maintenance
The lease decides who looks after the space. Commonly the landlord or its property manager handles the structure, roof and common areas and bills the tenant a share, while the tenant handles the inside of its space and its own equipment and, depending on the lease, the heating, cooling and other building systems. Where the lease is vague, disputes follow. A buyer often asks who the property manager is, how repair requests are handled, and which repairs are overdue. When the business owns its building, the property management agreement, maintenance contracts, building insurance and tax bills join the list to review and transfer.
Landlord consent and assignment
Most commercial leases say the tenant may not transfer the lease without the landlord’s written consent. Some say consent “may not be unreasonably withheld”; others leave it to the landlord’s discretion. The wording matters. An assignment moves the existing lease to the buyer. The alternative is a new lease between the landlord and the buyer, which the landlord can price at today’s market.
A landlord asked for consent often asks for something in return:
- the buyer’s financial statements, and sometimes proof of experience;
- a larger security deposit, or a personal guarantee from the buyer;
- higher rent, a different term, or a consent fee;
- a signed estoppel certificate, which is a statement by the landlord that the lease is in effect, what rent is paid, and that neither side is in default. A buyer asks the landlord for this.
Two points catch people. First, unless the landlord signs a release, the seller usually stays responsible for the lease after the assignment. That is why sellers ask for a release at closing, including from any guarantee. Second, in a stock purchase there may be no assignment at all, but a change-of-control clause can still require the landlord’s consent.
New York noteWhen a lease is transferred, or a controlling interest in a company that owns real property is sold, New York real estate transfer tax reporting (Form TP-584) can apply. The seller is expected to work out whether the tax is owed, and a buyer can owe it if the seller does not pay.
What usually needs consent
The lease is only the first item. This table lists what usually needs someone else’s approval when a business changes hands.
Consents and approvals, beyond permits
| What | Who must say yes | What usually happens | Watch for |
| Commercial lease | The landlord | Assignment with written consent, or a new lease | The seller stays liable unless released. The landlord may ask for financials, a deposit or a guarantee. |
| Bank loans and equipment leases | The lender or the equipment lessor | Paid off from the sale proceeds at closing, or the lender consents to the transfer | A payoff letter and a lien release for each. |
| Franchise agreement | The franchisor | Approval of the buyer, training, usually a new agreement and a transfer fee | A right of first refusal: the franchisor’s right to match the buyer’s offer. |
| Key customer and supplier contracts | The other party | An assignment clause or a change-of-control clause decides | A key contract that ends when ownership changes, or credit and exclusive terms that do not pass. |
| Software and technology licenses | The licensor | Consent to assign, or a new agreement | Some cannot be assigned without permission. |
| State or local government contracts | The awarding agency | Written consent to assign | Whether a share sale triggers consent depends on the contract itself. |
| Insurance | The insurer | The buyer’s own policies in force from closing | A gap on day one. Professional practices also look at tail coverage, which covers claims made after the policy ends. |
| Owners and partners | Co-owners, the board, or partners with a veto | A vote or written consent under the operating agreement or shareholder agreement | A right of first refusal or a buy-sell agreement that comes first. |
Licenses and permits: what transfers and what is applied for again
The New York State Tax Department’s own guidance says that most of a previous owner’s licenses and registrations do not transfer to a buyer. In an asset purchase the buyer generally applies for its own. The practical question is order: which applications can be filed before closing, which need a signed contract first, and which can run on a temporary permit, so the business never closes its doors between owners.
Licenses and permits that usually do not pass to a buyer
| What | Who approves | The usual path in New York | Watch for |
| Sales tax Certificate of Authority | NYS Tax Department | The buyer applies for its own, at least 20 days before taking over. | Applying late can mean no lawful sales tax collection on day one. See the bulk sale notice. |
| Liquor license | State Liquor Authority (SLA) | A license generally cannot be handed to a buyer. The buyer applies for its own, and may be able to operate under a temporary permit while that application is reviewed. | The permit needs a signed contract of sale and does not guarantee the full license. Even in a share purchase, the SLA generally must approve a change in who owns a licensed company. |
| County food-service permit | The county health department | The buyer generally applies for its own. | The process can be shorter if nothing about the kitchen or layout changes. |
| Contractor and trade licenses | City, county or state, depending on the trade | The holder is identified; then the buyer applies, or uses a qualifying person | A license held by the owner personally does not come with the sale. New York has no statewide general contractor license; many are local, so it depends on where the business works. |
| Professional licenses and practice ownership | State licensing bodies, and the Department of Health for some health care deals | A licensed buyer, with notice or approval where required | A professional LLC (PLLC) may be owned only by licensed professionals, and some health care deals require notice to the State Department of Health. |
A restaurant shows why the order matters: the lease, the liquor application, the county permit and the sales tax registration each have their own clock, and the slowest sets the date.
What is involved
Identifying consents early is what keeps a closing clean. The steps, in the order they usually happen:
- Step 1
List every contract and permit
Early in due diligence, collect the lease, every significant contract, loan and equipment lease, every license, permit and registration, and the owners’ agreements.
- Step 2
Read each one for transfer language
Look for assignment clauses, change-of-control clauses, rights of first refusal and termination rights, in a stock purchase as well.
- Step 3
Decide what must be in hand at closing
The important consents become conditions of the purchase agreement: the landlord, the franchisor, key customers, lender payoffs. Each condition names the document that proves it.
- Step 4
Start the slow items first
The landlord, the franchisor, the liquor authority and the county health department take longest. Applications that need a signed contract wait for it, so the contract date and the filing dates are planned together.
- Step 5
Collect the signed paper
Before closing, each consent is in writing, matches what the agreement describes, and is on the closing checklist. See closing and after.
Buyer and seller views
If you are buying
- Many buyers read the lease before the letter of intent. A weak lease changes what the business is worth.
- Buyers often keep a closing condition in place until the consent is signed.
- Many buyers decide in advance what the landlord may ask of them: financials, a deposit, a guarantee.
- Many buyers plan license and permit filings so there is no day without one.
If you are selling
- Sellers often talk to the landlord once a letter of intent is signed, and ask to be released from the lease and any guarantee.
- A seller cannot let a buyer operate under its liquor license or share the profits before the State Liquor Authority approves it, and stays responsible for violations under its license.
- Selling alcohol inventory separately needs its own permit from the SLA.
- Sellers often list key contracts early, so notice and consent requirements do not come as a surprise.