Checking the financials when you buy a business: records, cross-checks and red flags
Which records to ask for, how to compare them against each other, how to read add-backs and owner pay, and what a red flag looks like.
Checking the financials means testing the numbers a price rests on against records the seller cannot easily shape: tax returns, bank statements and the sales tax and payroll filings. Two documents that should agree and do not are where the real questions start. The result is a price you can defend, a changed price, or a reason to walk away.
Why the numbers need checking
A price is only as good as the numbers under it. Owner-run books are often built for tax filing or convenience, not for a buyer, and the owner’s pay, personal expenses and cash sales can blur what the business really earns.
The job is to see whether the story the seller tells matches the paper trail. This page is the buyer’s side. A seller preparing for this check can read getting ready to sell.
The records to ask for
- Business tax returns for the last three years.
- Profit and loss statements and balance sheets for the same years, the current year to date, and monthly statements for the last 24 months if they exist.
- Twelve to 24 months of bank statements for every business account.
- Sales tax returns, and payroll tax filings: the federal quarterly return (Form 941) and New York’s quarterly return (Form NYS-45).
- Receivables and payables aging reports: lists of what customers owe the business and what the business owes, sorted by how overdue each item is.
- Inventory records and the latest physical count.
- Loan, lease and credit-card agreements, with a schedule of every debt.
- For stores and restaurants, card-processor and delivery-platform statements and point-of-sale reports.
- Payroll registers and the employee list.
- The seller’s own list of add-backs (explained below), with proof for each.
What to compare against what
Any single document can be wrong. Two documents that should agree and do not are where the real questions start.
| Compare this | Against this | What a gap can mean |
|---|---|---|
| Sales on the profit and loss | Deposits on the bank statements, and for stores and restaurants, point-of-sale reports and processor statements | Cash that was never deposited or recorded, or sales that were overstated. |
| The financial statements | The tax returns | One set of numbers was shown to a lender and another to the IRS. Ask why. |
| Sales reported to you | Sales tax returns filed with New York | Under-reported sales, or unpaid tax that can follow the buyer. |
| Payroll expense | Payroll tax filings and the employee list | People paid off the books, or contractors who are really employees. |
| Receivables aging | Invoices and the payments received since | Customers who will not pay, or sales that were never real. |
| Inventory on the balance sheet | A physical count you attend | Stock that is old, damaged or not there. |
| Debts on the seller’s schedule | Lender statements and lien searches | Debts the seller forgot, or liens that must be paid off at closing. |
| Sales by customer | Contracts and the last three years of sales | A large share of revenue that depends on one customer. |
- A restaurant’s profit and loss shows steady sales, but the bank deposits run well below it, month after month. Either cash was not deposited or reported, or sales were overstated. Neither can be paid for.
- A store’s books show strong sales, but the sales tax returns filed with New York report less. Either the books overstate sales or the returns understate them, and unpaid tax can follow a buyer.
- A contractor’s statements show a profit, but the schedule of open jobs shows costs piling up on several jobs that have not been booked yet. The profit may be a matter of timing.
Add-backs and owner pay
An add-back is an adjustment the seller makes to reported profit to show what the business earns for a new owner. Common ones are personal expenses run through the company, one-time costs, and an owner’s pay that was unusually high. Small businesses are often priced on seller’s discretionary earnings (SDE): profit plus the owner’s pay and the add-backs.
Ask of each add-back: is it documented, is it really one-time, and will it actually go away after you take over? A “one-time” repair that appears every year is an ordinary cost.
Owner pay cuts the other way. An owner who works full time and takes little salary makes the business look more profitable than it will be for a buyer who has to hire a manager. Many buyers adjust profit to what a replacement would cost at market pay.
Some buyers, and some lenders, call for an independent review of the earnings number, the add-backs and the level of working capital. That is a quality of earnings report. For an SBA-backed purchase, the lender is generally required to obtain an independent business valuation, though it may do its own at $350,000 or less, and a quality of earnings report is generally required at $3 million and above under SBA’s rules. See SBA financing.
Sales tax and payroll tax filings
Ask for every sales tax return and the proof of payment. Unpaid sales tax is the debt most likely to follow a buyer in New York, because of the bulk sale rule.
For payroll, confirm that withholding and unemployment insurance filings were made and paid, and that the number of people on the filings matches the employee list. Workers paid off the books, or called contractors when the law treats them as employees, are a liability that can follow the business.
A New York buyer may also take over the seller’s unemployment insurance rating, and the Department of Labor has a notice process.
Bank statements, receivables, payables and debts
Bank statements
Look at every account, not only the main one. Match deposits to reported sales, then look at transfers between accounts, owner draws, loan money that was booked as sales, and personal spending paid by the company.
Receivables
Use the aging report and the payments received since. Items that are very old are unlikely to be collected, and a few large customers owing a lot is a risk of its own.
Payables
A business can look more profitable by paying its bills late. An aging report with many items far past due, or with unpaid rent, payroll taxes or sales taxes, shows a business short of cash. In an asset purchase the contract lists which bills the buyer takes on; in a stock purchase they all come along.
Debts and other claims
Build a schedule from the books, the lender statements and the public record searches, and compare. Include personal guarantees, equipment leases, credit cards, and amounts the business owes its customers: deposits, prepaid orders and gift cards. The levels of receivables, inventory and payables at closing also feed the working-capital adjustment.
What a red flag looks like
These patterns are not proof of anything. Each is a reason to ask for the records behind it.
| What you see | What it may mean | What to ask for |
|---|---|---|
| Two versions of the numbers, one for the bank and one for the IRS | Profit reported differently depending on who is reading | Both versions, and a written reconciliation. |
| Sales rising while deposits stay flat | Sales overstated, or cash taken out before deposit | Point-of-sale reports, processor statements and every bank account. |
| Add-backs that repeat every year | Costs called one-time that are really recurring | An invoice for each year’s add-back. |
| Profit that jumps in the year the business is listed | Costs delayed or moved to another period | Monthly statements for 24 months and an explanation of the change. |
| Payables far older than usual, or unpaid payroll or sales taxes | The business is short of cash, and the debts will land on the buyer or be paid out of the price | Aging reports and proof of each tax payment. |
| Owner pay far below the cost of a replacement manager | Profit overstated for a buyer who has to hire | Profit adjusted to market pay. |
| The seller will not give you bank statements or tax returns | The numbers cannot be checked, and a lender will not lend without them | Many buyers treat it as a reason to lower the price or leave. |
What is involved
The practical steps, in the order they usually happen.
- Request the records at the start of the diligence period, as one list. See the due diligence period.
- Put the documents side by side. Statements, tax returns, bank deposits and filings are compared, and every gap is marked.
- Test each add-back and adjust owner pay to market. Most buyers have an accountant run these tests, and a lender may require an independent valuation or quality of earnings report.
- Count and compare. Attend the inventory count, and compare receivables with the payments that came in afterward.
- Build the debt schedule from the books, the lender statements and the public searches.
- Decide what each finding changes: the price, the working-capital target, or the promises in the contract. See representations and warranties for how a financial-statements promise is written.
Questions about checking the numbers
Short answers. For your own deal, the best answer comes from a conversation.
What if the seller will not give me the books?
Do I need an accountant to review the financials?
Are add-backs legitimate?
What if the financial statements and the tax returns do not match?
Where we work. Seraj Law is a Capital Region firm with clients across New York State. See the counties and towns we serve.
Attorney Advertising
The information on this website is for general informational purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.
Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Talk to an attorney about your deal.
Reach out to us. We quote a flat fee for the work. Open 7 days a week, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m.
This page provides general legal information about checking a business’s financial records before buying it in New York and is not legal advice. Do not send confidential information through this site before we have agreed to represent you.