Skip to main content
Seraj Law
Mergers & Acquisitions · Buyers and sellers

Buying or selling a distressed business in New York

Foreclosure sales, receivership, assignments for the benefit of creditors and bankruptcy sales: how each works, what a buyer must research, and what an owner in trouble must understand. Seraj Law is a Capital Region firm that represents business buyers and sellers across New York State.

The short answer

A distressed business in New York is usually sold in one of five ways: by the owner before a default, by a secured lender after a default, through a court-appointed receiver, through an assignment for the benefit of creditors, or in bankruptcy under section 363 of the Bankruptcy Code. Each route gives the buyer different protection against the seller’s debts and gives the seller different exposure to creditors. Speed can be what you trade for that protection: the faster the sale, the less a buyer may be able to check and the less a seller may be able to negotiate. Seraj Law helps buyers and sellers with the sale itself; a debtor’s own bankruptcy filing may need bankruptcy counsel.

Five ways a troubled business is sold

Which route applies depends on who controls the assets and whether a court is involved. Find out which one you are in first.

The five routes compared
RouteHow the sale worksWhat it means for a buyer
Sale by the owner, before a defaultAn ordinary negotiated sale, often using the price to pay creditors, before a lender or court takes control.The usual contract protections can be negotiated, but only as good as the seller’s ability to pay. A creditor can challenge a transfer made for too little value.
Secured lender’s sale (UCC Article 9)After a default, a lender with a security interest in business assets can sell them, publicly or privately, if every aspect of the sale is commercially reasonable.Only the collateral is sold, not the company. The buyer gets the debtor’s rights in it, usually with no warranties.
ReceivershipA court appoints a receiver to take and hold property. The court sets the receiver’s powers, which can include selling.The court order defines what the receiver may sell and on what terms.
Assignment for the benefit of creditorsThe owner transfers its assets by a written assignment, recorded with the county clerk, to an assignee who sells them and pays creditors (Debtor and Creditor Law, Article 2).The buyer purchases what the company owned. An assignee often promises little.
Sale in bankruptcy (section 363)A trustee, or a business still in control as a debtor in possession, asks the bankruptcy court to approve a sale outside the ordinary course, after notice and a hearing.The court’s sale order is the buyer’s protection. It can allow a sale free and clear of liens in listed situations.

When a secured lender sells the collateral

A security interest is a lender’s claim on specific business assets, such as equipment, inventory or receivables, which it can enforce after a default. In New York, Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code governs the sale.

  • Commercially reasonable. The method, manner, time, place and terms must all be commercially reasonable (UCC 9-610).
  • Notice. The lender generally must notify the debtor, any guarantor-type obligor and other secured parties of record. In a business deal, notice sent at least 10 days before the sale date is treated as timely. Perishable goods and goods sold on a recognized market need no notice (9-611, 9-612).
  • What the buyer gets. The debtor’s rights in the collateral. The foreclosing lender’s security interest and junior liens on it end, and a good-faith buyer takes free of them even if the lender broke the rules (9-617).
  • As-is. A sale carries an implied warranty of title unless the lender disclaims it in the words the statute describes, and lender sale documents commonly do (9-610).
  • Real estate is separate. A mortgage on real property is foreclosed by court action under Article 13 of the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law.

Buying in bankruptcy: sections 363 and 365

In chapter 7 a trustee sells the debtor’s nonexempt property. In chapter 11 the debtor usually stays in control and may sell the business instead of reorganizing it. A sale outside the ordinary course needs court approval under section 363 of the Bankruptcy Code.

  • Notice and timing. Creditors generally get at least 21 days’ notice unless the court shortens it, and a sale order is stayed 14 days unless the court orders otherwise (Bankruptcy Rules 2002(a)(2), 6004(h)).
  • Free and clear. A sale free of another party’s interest is allowed only if one of five things is true: other law permits it, the holder consents, the interest is a lien and the price exceeds all liens, the interest is in bona fide dispute, or the holder could be forced to take money (363(f)).
  • Credit bidding and good faith. A lienholder can bid its debt unless the court orders otherwise for cause (363(k)). A later reversal on appeal does not undo a sale to a good-faith buyer unless the sale was stayed (363(m)).
  • Contracts and leases. With court approval a contract or lease can be assumed and assigned to the buyer despite a clause barring assignment, if defaults are cured (or cure is assured) and the buyer gives adequate assurance of future performance. Contracts the law lets the other side refuse to move to a new party need consent (section 365).
  • Store and warehouse leases. A nonresidential lease where the debtor is the tenant is treated as rejected if not assumed within 120 days after filing, with one 90-day extension for cause (365(d)(4)).

What a buyer must research

A distressed seller has less time and money to answer questions, so the buyer’s own research carries more weight. See due diligence and risk research.

  • Liens and security interests. UCC, judgment and tax lien searches against the seller, including earlier names. A security interest generally follows the collateral to a buyer unless the lender authorized the sale free of it (UCC 9-315).
  • Taxes. Sales tax, payroll withholding and income taxes the seller owes. In a private asset purchase from a seller that collects sales tax, the buyer files the bulk sale notice: see the bulk sale page.
  • Employees. Unpaid wages and benefits, who stays, and notice duties if jobs end. New York’s WARN rules generally require 90 days’ notice of covered closings and layoffs by employers with 50 or more full-time employees. See employees and key people.
  • Successor liability. An asset buyer in New York is generally not liable for the seller’s debts, with four exceptions: the buyer agrees to take them on, the deal is a de facto merger, the buyer is a mere continuation of the seller, or the deal is a fraud on creditors (Schumacher v. Richards Shear Co., 59 N.Y.2d 239 (1983)). Same owners, name, staff and location are the facts courts look at.
  • Contracts, leases, permits and licenses. Which can be assigned, what consent is needed, what a cure costs, and which licenses the buyer must apply for itself. See leases, licenses and consents.

What an owner in trouble must understand

  • Creditors are paid in an order set by contract and law. A secured lender is paid from its collateral first, and unsecured creditors share what is left. A sale for less than the secured debt leaves the difference owed (UCC 9-615).
  • A personal guarantee does not end because the business is sold. If you guaranteed a loan, the lender can look to you for a shortfall unless it releases you in writing.
  • Moving assets can be undone. A creditor can undo a transfer made with intent to hinder, delay or defraud a creditor, or for less than reasonably equivalent value when the debtor could not pay debts as they came due (Debtor and Creditor Law 273). Courts weigh a sale to an insider, keeping control of what was sold, and a transfer after a lawsuit was threatened. A bankruptcy trustee can also recover certain transfers.
  • Some debts can reach owners personally. Responsible persons can be liable for unpaid sales and withholding tax. The ten largest shareholders of a non-public corporation can be liable for unpaid employee wages after written notice from the employee (Business Corporation Law 630).

Speed against protection, and what goes wrong

A fast sale of a failing business trades protection for time. The trade looks different from each side.

For the buyer

  • Little or no promise from the seller, and a seller that may have no money to back one.
  • A short window to check liens, contracts and taxes.
  • Harder financing: lenders look closely at the business’s history and debts, and may lend less or ask for more cash.

For the seller

  • Less room to negotiate when a lender or court process sets the price and buyer.
  • A sale may release liens on assets but not your personal guarantee.
  • What you tell buyers must be accurate. A fraud claim is generally not limited by a contract cap.

Common ways these deals go wrong, in general terms: a buyer assumes assets are lien-free and the sale did not discharge a lien; a key lease or contract cannot be assigned and the other side resets its terms; a needed permit does not pass; the buyer keeps the same owners, name and staff and is treated as a continuation of the seller; the seller moves assets to a new company before the sale and a court or trustee reverses it.

What is involved

  1. Identify the route and the paper that controls it: loan and security documents, the lender’s notice of sale, the receivership order, the assignment, or the bankruptcy docket.
  2. Find out who has a claim: lien, judgment and tax searches, a creditor list, guarantees and leases.
  3. Define what is bought or sold: assets and assumed contracts listed, excluded debts named. See asset or stock.
  4. Check what can transfer: leases, licenses, permits and customer contracts, consents, and the cost to cure defaults.
  5. Set how it is paid and protected: price, deposit, escrow or holdback where the seller has money behind it, payoff letters and lien releases at closing.
  6. Make the New York filings and notices: the bulk sale notice where it applies and WARN notices where jobs end.
  7. Close and finish: sign, record releases, move the assets, and tell customers, vendors and employees.
What we help with

Seraj Law helps buyers and sellers with the sale transaction in these situations: the research, the purchase agreement and the closing. A debtor’s own bankruptcy filing, and running a bankruptcy case, may need bankruptcy counsel.

Questions

Questions about distressed businesses

Short answers. For your own situation, the answer depends on the route and the documents.

If I buy at a lender’s sale, do I get the business free of its debts?
Not all of them. A buyer in good faith takes the collateral free of the foreclosing lender’s security interest and of junior liens on it, but the sale covers only that collateral. It does not clear the company’s other debts, move its lease or pass its licenses. See the lender’s sale rules above.
Can a creditor undo a sale I make before filing anything?
It can try if the sale looks like an effort to keep assets from creditors, or if the price was well below what the assets were worth and you could not pay your debts. A sale to an insider at a low price draws scrutiny. See what an owner must understand.
I guaranteed the business loan. Does selling the business release me?
Not by itself. Unless the lender agrees in writing to release you, you can still owe any shortfall after the collateral is sold.
Where we work. Seraj Law is a Capital Region firm with its office in Albany, and we represent buyers and sellers across New York State. See the counties and towns we work in

Attorney Advertising

The information on this website is for general informational purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Talk to an attorney about your deal.

Reach out to us. We quote a flat fee for the work. Open 7 days a week, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m.

This page provides general legal information about distressed business sales in New York and is not legal advice or tax advice. Do not send confidential information through this site before we have agreed to represent you.