Skip to main content
Seraj Law
Mergers & Acquisitions · Buyers and sellers

Non-compete and transition agreements when you sell a business in New York

What a buyer asks the seller to promise after closing, what a New York court looks at, and what a transition or consulting agreement needs to say. Seraj Law is a Capital Region firm that represents business buyers and sellers across New York State.

The short answer

A non-compete is the seller’s promise not to run or work for a competing business for a set time and area after the sale. Buyers ask for one because they are paying for goodwill. In New York, courts generally enforce one that is reasonable in time, area and scope. A transition agreement is separate: it sets how long the seller stays to hand over customers and processes, in what role and for what pay.

Why a buyer asks for a non-compete

A buyer is paying for goodwill, the reasons customers keep coming back. It does not want the seller to sell the business and open across the street the next month. Three related promises protect what the buyer paid for:

  • Non-compete: the seller promises not to run, own or work for a competing business for a set time within a set area.
  • A non-solicit is narrower: the seller promises not to approach the buyer’s customers, or its employees, to take them away. It does not stop the seller from working in the industry.
  • A confidentiality promise: the seller promises not to use or share what it knows about the business’s pricing, customers and methods.

A buyer often asks for all three. They are usually signed at closing and attached to the purchase agreement, and the letter of intent usually says the buyer will ask for them.

What is typical, and what gets negotiated

The terms vary a great deal by business. What a buyer asks for first is rarely what ends up in the agreement. The points that get negotiated are the same in most deals:

The terms of a non-compete in a business sale
TermWhat it coversPoints to negotiate
TimeHow long after closing the restriction lasts. In small-business sales the starting point is often the length of time the buyer needs to build its own customer relationships.A buyer asks for long enough to hold the customers. A seller asks that it run from closing, not from the end of any consulting period, and that it not be longer than the buyer needs.
GeographyWhere the seller may not compete.A radius around the locations, a list of counties, or, for a business that sells by delivery or online, the territory where customers actually are. A seller asks for the area where the business really operates, not a whole state.
The business restrictedWhat kind of work is off limits.The business that was sold, not “any business.” Carve-outs for passive investments, a job with a firm that does not compete, retirement, and the seller’s other businesses.
Who is boundThe seller, and sometimes its owners, family members or partners.Each additional person bound needs a reason. Each person who signs gets a say.
What happens on a breachThe buyer’s remedies if the seller competes.Whether the buyer can ask a court for an order to stop it, whether it can recover its lawyer fees, and whether a breach affects the seller’s remaining payments (a seller note, earnout or escrow release).
Tie to the priceHow much of the price is attributed to the promise.A figure for the non-compete is a tax item and also tells a court the buyer paid for it. See “The price and tax side” below.

New York enforceability

New York note

Courts in New York generally decide whether a non-compete is enforceable by asking whether it is reasonable in time, in area and in scope, and whether it protects a legitimate interest of the buyer. A non-compete given by the seller in a sale of a business is generally looked at more readily than one given by an employee, because the buyer paid for the goodwill.

A court that finds a non-compete too broad may, in some circumstances, enforce it only to the extent it is reasonable instead of throwing it out. That is why many non-competes are written narrowly rather than broadly.

Bills to restrict non-competes are pending in the legislature; we check the current status.

Federal rules on non-competes have also been the subject of rulemaking and court challenges, so the law at the time you sign controls. A non-solicit of customers and employees is often easier to defend than a non-compete, and in some businesses protects the buyer almost as well.

The price and tax side

The amount of the price attributed to a non-compete matters for taxes. For the buyer, a non-compete entered into in connection with an acquisition is a Section 197 intangible, recovered over 15 years like goodwill, and it sits in a different IRS asset class (Class VI) than goodwill (Class VII). Amounts paid for a non-compete are generally taxed to the seller as ordinary income. Because each side’s tax result differs, the figure is negotiated, and each side’s accountant usually runs the numbers. See price allocation.

What each side asks for

What a buyer asks for

  • A non-compete and a non-solicit long enough to cover the time needed to hold the customers.
  • An area that matches where the business has customers.
  • Everyone who benefits from the sale, or who can hurt the business, to be bound.
  • The right to ask a court for an order to stop a breach.
  • A transition period in which the seller introduces customers and trains staff.

What a seller negotiates

  • Length and area no wider than the buyer’s real need.
  • A definition of the restricted business that is the business sold, not “any business.”
  • Carve-outs for passive investments, a non-competing job and retirement.
  • A clear start date and no automatic extension.
  • Limits on how a breach affects remaining payments, and a notice-and-cure period before the buyer can act.

Transition and consulting agreements

If the buyer needs the seller to stay for a while to introduce customers, train staff and hand over the processes, the deal includes a transition agreement. The seller may stay as an employee or work as an independent consultant. The agreement defines, in writing, what the work is, how long it lasts and what it pays.

What to define in a transition or consulting agreement
TermWhat to defineWhy it matters
Role and dutiesWhat the seller will do: introduce customers, train staff, answer questions, handle named accounts or projects.A vague role invites disputes about whether the seller is doing enough.
Hours and availabilitySet hours, on-call time, or a cap on hours per week.A seller who is also running something else, or retiring, needs the limit stated.
Length and end dateA fixed term, with any extension. The length usually reflects how much customers depend on the seller, not a number picked in advance.A transition that drifts on becomes an unplanned employment relationship.
PayA fee, salary, or a payment tied to milestones, and expenses.Consulting fees are generally ordinary income to the seller, unlike payment for goodwill, so the split between price and pay is a tax question.
Employee or consultantEmployee: payroll taxes withheld and benefits as agreed. Consultant: the seller pays its own taxes, and the buyer does not control how the work is done.A person called a consultant who works like an employee can be reclassified. New York looks at the actual relationship, not the label.
AuthorityWhether the seller may sign contracts, order goods or speak for the business after closing.The buyer usually wants none; customers may still call the seller.
Early endWhether either side may end it early and whether the buyer still owes the rest of the fees.Without a clause, the buyer may pay for a role it no longer needs or the seller may lose the income it counted on.
Link to the priceThat the price does not depend on the seller staying, unless the deal says so on purpose.A transition tied to price becomes an earnout in disguise.
Financing note

If the buyer uses an SBA 7(a) loan, the seller generally may not stay on as an officer, director, stockholder or employee in an initial acquisition. A consulting agreement is allowed for up to 24 months in total. See SBA financing. Key employees may also be asked to sign new agreements at closing as a condition of the sale: see employees and key people.

What is involved

  1. Decide what the buyer is protecting: the customer base, a method, a territory, a few key relationships.
  2. Define the restricted business and the area, with the carve-outs, in terms that can be tested against the actual business.
  3. Set the length and the start date, and whether anything pauses or extends it.
  4. Draft the promises: non-compete, non-solicit, confidentiality, and any limit on hiring the buyer’s staff.
  5. Decide the remedies: court orders, fees, effect on remaining payments, notice and a chance to fix.
  6. Attribute part of the price if the deal calls for it, with each side’s accountant.
  7. If there is a transition period, write the role, hours, length, pay and early-end terms, and decide employee or consultant.
  8. Check the lender’s rules if the buyer is financing the purchase, and sign everything at closing as exhibits to the purchase agreement.
Questions

Questions about non-competes and transition

Short answers. The law on non-competes is changing, so the answer for your deal depends on when you sign.

Can the seller open a competing business after the sale?
Only if the agreement allows it. A buyer normally asks for a non-compete and a non-solicit for a set time and area. The seller can negotiate carve-outs, such as passive investments or a job with a firm that does not compete. Without any non-compete, a seller is legally free to compete, although confidentiality and trade-secret rules still limit what it can use.
Are non-competes enforceable in New York?
Generally, if they are reasonable in time, area and scope and protect a legitimate interest. The sale of a business is a setting where they are looked at favorably. Bills to restrict non-competes have been introduced, so the law at the time you sign is what counts.
What is the difference between a non-compete and a non-solicit?
A non-compete bars the seller from the competing business altogether. A non-solicit bars only approaching the buyer’s customers or employees. A non-solicit is narrower, easier to defend and leaves the seller free to work in the industry.
Do I have to stay on after the sale?
Not unless the agreement says so. Many sales have a short transition period, and some buyers want a longer one. If the buyer is using an SBA loan, the seller’s role after closing may be limited. The length and pay of any transition are usually written down before closing.
Where we work. Seraj Law is a Capital Region firm with its office in Albany, and we represent buyers and sellers across New York State. See the counties and towns we work in

Attorney Advertising

The information on this website is for general informational purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Talk to an attorney about your deal.

Reach out to us. We quote a flat fee for the work. Open 7 days a week, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m.

This page provides general legal information about non-compete and transition agreements in a business sale in New York and is not legal advice or tax advice. Do not send confidential information through this site before we have agreed to represent you.